Skip to content
  • About
  • Staff
  • 1953-1970
  • Print Edition
  • Advertising
  • Contact
  • Write for us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Comment Policy
Search for:
Trinity News

Trinity News

Ireland's Oldest Student Newspaper

Skip to content
  • News
  • Features
  • Editorial
  • Comment
  • Gaeilge
  • Life
  • SciTech
  • Sport
  • Podcasts
  • Video
Comment
10 October 2023
via Sky News

Manchester United made the correct decision on Mason Greenwood, but the public outcry holding them to account should not have been necessary.

Nina Crofts examines the public outcry over Mason Greenwood’s sexual assault allegations, and why the club’s response was somewhat murky.

Nina Crofts

Since allegations of abuse and assault first came out against Manchester United player Mason Greenwood in January 2022, it has been one of the most contentious topics in my family, particularly between my dad and I. 

I’ve been a Man U supporter since I was a baby wearing a tiny Ryan Giggs jersey, and have watched the successes and failures of the club almost every weekend during the Premier League season. I’ve never feigned expertise in football: my fantasy team is subpar and I often ask my dad pretty stupid questions about the sport. 

But in recent years, I’ve had far more passion for the business and social justice sides of football rather than the technical aspects. I’m up to speed on the Glazers’ sale of the club and even more on Marcus Rashford’s advocacy around ensuring that children have access to hot meals during school lunchtimes.

So when allegations against Mason Greenwood came out early last year, I was crushed. He looked to be a really strong player with a similar background to Rashford, and loads of fans saw him as having come really far within the team. Even talking to my dad about the allegations in those early days, there seemed to have been a general condemnation of Greenwood and that he had no further place within the team or within professional football.

Earlier this year, however, the prosecution’s case against Greenwood was dropped due to the withdrawal of key witnesses and the emergence of new evidence. Neither of these reasons for dropping the case were ever elaborated on. This prompted numerous discussions with my dad and other male extended family members about Greenwood and how, according to them, he shouldn’t have a mistake that he made as a young man follow him and ruin his career.

His guilt is not absolved because his victim no longer wishes to prosecute the crime.

However, the withdrawal of a key witness and of new evidence (especially as there are no specifics available as to its contents) does not mean it was a mistake or that he did not commit the crimes of which he was accused. His guilt is not absolved because his victim no longer wishes to prosecute the crime. Victims of sexual violence choose not to prosecute the perpetrators for a multitude of reasons, including fear of isolation, lack of support, or public backlash. With her alleged perpetrator being a very public figure, these fears are all inherent in the victim’s situation.

The most damning evidence, which will never absolve itself, are the recordings of him speaking to his girlfriend at the time. While persuading her to have sex, Greenwood remarks: “I don’t give a fuck what you want, you little shit” in response to her statements about not wanting to engage in sexual intercourse. Throughout the exchange he asks her to “move her fucking legs up,” refers to her as a “twat,” and shows a blatant disregard for consent. 

Manchester United made the correct decision by not allowing Greenwood to return, but their exact motives for doing so cause some scepticism. About a week before the decision, it was leaked that the team intended to slowly bring him back to the squad. It was incredibly poorly timed, falling on the day the English women’s team secured a place in the 2023 World Cup final. It was met by mass controversy, largely from women’s sport networks and a significant portion of the Man U fanbase. Though it isn’t confirmed, one could heavily suspect that the club’s changing stance on the decision only a few days later was prompted by this public backlash.

Having Greenwood absolved of his allegations after having heard the recording, it would be a travesty to have him displayed on a national scale as a face of the team, and an insult to all fans who are victims of gender-based violence.

Greenwood was a young man when the allegations were made. Mason and his girlfriend are still involved in a relationship, and whatever healing is occurring between the two of them is necessary and also private. Having Greenwood absolved of his allegations after having heard the recording, it would be a travesty to have him displayed on a national scale as a face of the team, and an insult to all fans who are victims of gender-based violence.

It was undeniably a precarious situation. The club put faith into the justice system to decide Greenwood’s fate, and the justice system failed to deliver a verdict. The United Kingdom’s justice system is failing women at an alarming rate, with a steep decline of domestic abuse convictions reported only last year. Additionally, it takes on average almost two years to reach trial stage in most cases of reported rape. That can lead to a victim doubting themselves or their story, as they often receive no updates on the status of their case.

In a legal sense, Greenwood is not guilty, but is also not innocent. To have him wear a red jersey on the pitch of Old Trafford would destroy the club’s reputation. A strong forward is not worth complacency and apathy towards perpetrators of violence and rape in any way, shape, or form. Manchester United made the correct decision, but the public outcry holding them to account should not have been necessary.

No Responses

Nina Crofts

Related Posts

22 OCT

Misdiagnosis and the portrayal of mental health on TikTok

In an era where TikTok has almost replaced psychiatrists, Isabella Roussel discusses the dangers of diagnosing ourselves via the social...

Comment Read More
21 OCT

Is the full college experience a myth?

Starting college can elicit anxieties in students around ensuring they get the so-called “full college experience.” While of course we...

Comment Read More
26 SEP

A terrible beauty is born: history repeats itself at the Wolfe Tones’ Electric Picnic set.

Like many students, I made the pilgrimage to Stradbally, County Laois for the annual Electric Picnic festival, and flocked to the Electric...

Comment Read More
25 SEP

The Flow State: What, How and Why?

Have you ever found yourself so immersed in a task or activity that hours pass in what feels like minutes? This occurrence is known in...

Comment Read More
22 SEP

The DART+ Programme: A revolutionary expansion or a restrictive hindrance?

In the past few months, Irish Rail have outlined plans to expand the DART (Dublin Area Rapid Transit) past the small coastal commuter area...

Comment Read More

Recent Posts

  • The overlooked issue of passport privilege 3 November 2023
  • Roleplaying adulthood 2 November 2023
  • Dublin’s fair city: Pol Soc’s first speaker event of the year 1 November 2023
  • The Straker controversy: diversity in the kitchen 1 November 2023
  • The stories behind the vests: getting to know Trinity Security 1 November 2023

Most Popular

  1. UCC opens sleeping pod in library
    The pod allows users to take a 20 minute nap
  2. The struggles and contributions of Marie Curie
    Katarzyna Siewierska writes about Marie Curie as a tribute to all female scientists, who made contributions to science, but also showed strength of character and determination in overcoming the challenges of being a female scientist, inspiring generations of female scientists
  3. Eamon Ryan forced to use emergency exit as PWO protest outside lecture theatre
    Ryan’s address had already been disrupted by a group of student activists who condemned the government’s policies.
  4. Fifth Trinity student tests positive for Covid-19
    Two cases were announced yesterday
  5. “Adderall’s quite popular in Trinity”: an interview with a student drug dealer
    A Trinity student details the trials and tribulations of dealing
  6. Outcry from student midwives over bullying “rife in our Irish hospitals”
    Reports of unfair treatment are growing amongst midwifery and nursing students on placement following new online anti-bullying campaign
  7. Arrested Trinity student Conchúir Ó Ráidigh speaks out on his injuries
    Ó Ráidigh went to hospital last night with multiple injuries after being arrested
  8. Editorial: Bugging has destroyed the integrity of the University Times
    Any student is liable to bugging if the University Times does not face serious consequences
  9. Bed bugs bite in Botany Bay
    A student reports being bitten this weekend
  10. USI pass emergency motion to support the Take Back the City protest
    The motion was tabled by TCDSU

Irish Press Council

Trinity News is a member of the Press Council of Ireland and supports the Office of the Press Ombudsman. For more information or to contact the Ombudsman visit the Press Ombudsman's website.

Copyright Trinity News 2025 Theme by Alden Mathieu
This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish.Accept Privacy Policy
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT